13 Reasons To Try Fabio's NY Pizza On High Street In Charlottesville

1. Meet The Gentlemen Behind Fabio’s NY Pizza!

1551 E High St, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
Website | Facebook | Photo: CVille Photo & Video

Fabio’s NY Pizza has enjoyed a loyal following in Charlottesville since 2008 when Mike Scotto took over the small restaurant serving pizzas, subs and traditional Italian dishes. While growing up in Monte Di Procida Naples Italy, Mike worked at a local restaurant and his passion for cooking was born. Mike’s dream was to own his own restaurant. In 2000, Mike decided to embark on a life-changing journey and moved to the United States to make his dreams come true.

Today, Mike and his business partner, Fabio, own Fabio’s NY Pizza on High Street. Fabio recently moved to Charlottesville, and partnered with his childhood friend, Mike. Fabio has tremendous restaurant experience. He has owned restaurants in Maryland and Salem, Va.

Together, Mike and Fabio are building Fabio’s NY Pizza into an Italian destination that all Charlottesville foodies should try. When you walk into the doors, you will most likely see Mike and Fabio on-site, overseeing the operations and greeting every customer with a warm smile.

Mike and Fabio are excited to celebrate their 10-year anniversary just around the corner. The Fabio’s NY Pizza Family is grateful of the support it has received from the Charlottesville community!

2. Fabio’s NY Pizza Uses The Freshest Ingredients!

1551 E High St, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
Website | Facebook | Photo: CVille Photo & Video

You will be able to taste the freshness with each Fabio’s NY Pizza dish. The food is literally made right in front of you. Personally, that goes a long way for me. Fresh food always tastes better.

3. Fabio’s NY Pizza Serves Some Of The Best Pies In Charlottesville

1551 E High St, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
Website | Facebook | Photo: CVille Photo & Video

The pizza at Fabio’s is as authentic as it gets! With multiple sizes and options to choose from, Fabio’s NY Pizza will make a couple on date night happy or feed the entire family on the weekend. The picture above is a medium “White Gourmet Pizza” served with spinach, broccoli, fresh tomatoes, white sauce, garlic and mozzarella cheese.

4. Fabio’s Famous Cheese Steak Sub, The Best Cheese Steak In Charlottesville

1551 E High St, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
Website | Facebook | Photo: CVille Photo & Video

The Fabio’s “Cheese Steak Sub” might be the best cheese steak in Charlottesville. Seriously. This Bad Boy comes with a choice of toppings that includes lettuce, tomato, mayo, peppers, onions and mushrooms. Add bacon to your cheese steak, and you just might be eating the best sub in CVille.

5. Fabio’s NY Pizza Garlic Knots

1551 E High St, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
Website | Facebook | Photo: CVille Photo & Video

When you walk into Fabio’s NY Pizza, you see a mountain of garlic knots behind the glass counter. When you make eye contact with The Knots, there is no turning back!! You B-Line straight for The Knots and order a pile to eat. Some you share, some you save for yourself. I order 12 garlic knots for $5 bucks every single time. That is such an amazing price!! Get The Knots now with Fabio’s Famous Tomato Sauce!

6. Made to Order Calzones

1551 E High St, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
Website | Facebook | Photo: CVille Photo & Video

The made-to-order Calzones (medium is $7.50, large is $13.75) are oven baked to perfection and served with your choice of one topping and mozzarella and ricotta. This meal will fill you up and leave you happy!

7. Order The Pepperoni Pizza!!

1551 E High St, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
Website | Facebook | Photo: Yelp

If you can’t decide what Pie to order, I suggest the Pepperoni Pie! Seriously, you can’t go wrong with this classic pizza. The pepperonis are large and in charge!

8. Enjoy The Specials At Fabio’s Pizza NY!

1551 E High St, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
Website | Facebook | Photo: CVille Photo & Video

The customer loyalty at Fabio’s NY Pizza is so strong that their customers beg them not to change their specials. Think about that! One current customer favorite is the “Flatbread Pizza” made with grilled chicken, onions, mushrooms and roasted red peppers drizzled with cheese sauce and pesto. For only $8.99, this meal can feed two people! All specials are served with choice of salad or fries and a drink!

9. The Combo Options At Fabio’s NY Pizza Are Fantastic (Available 11 AM – 3 PM Daily!)

1551 E High St, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
Website | Facebook | Photo: CVille Photo & Video

There are 10 fantastic combos to choose from each day. The combo menu is a great way to try the entire menu.

10. Fabio’s NY Pizza Is Conveniently Located Near I-64, The Bypass, Downtown And Pantops!

1551 E High St, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
Website | Facebook | Photo: CVille Photo & Video

Fabio’s NY Pizza is only minutes from I-64, the Bypass, Belmont, The Downtown Mall, Pantops, North Downtown and the Rugby Neighborhood. Hell, I drive to Fabio’s NY Pizza on High Street from the Redfields Neighborhood for my Italian fix!

11. Parking Is Easy At Fabio’s NY Pizza!

1551 E High St, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
Website | Facebook | Photo: CVille Photo & Video

You will never struggle to find parking at Fabio’s NY Pizza. Get in, get out, come back. It’s that simple.

12. Did you know Fabio’s NY Pizza Has A Catering Menu?

1551 E High St, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
Website | Facebook | Photo: CVille Photo & Video

Next time the in-laws are coming to town, consider these catering options: A half-tray or full-tray of lasagna! A half-tray of lasagna will run you only $45! Seriously, a half-tray will feed sooo many people, and there’s no hassle or clean up on your end! Also, don’t forget an order of garlic knots for dipping!